“High Court Judges Should Not Act as Domain Experts,” Supreme Court Warns — Here’s Why the Remark Was Made
New Delhi: The Supreme Court of India has strongly cautioned constitutional court judges against assuming the role of subject experts while deciding cases. The apex court observed that High Court judges should not behave like “super-examiners” or domain specialists, as such an approach could be “dangerous” and may distract them from their primary constitutional duty of adjudicating disputes impartially.
The remark was made by a bench comprising Chief Justice Suryakant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice N.V. Anjaria while hearing a petition filed by the Jharkhand Public Service Commission (JPSC).
What Was the Case About?
The petition challenged a Jharkhand High Court order related to the recruitment of judicial officers. The High Court had directed that candidates appearing in th...









