“Not Cut Out to Be an All-Format Captain”: Former England Spinner Critiques Shubman Gill

New Delhi: Former England left-arm spinner Monty Panesar has raised concerns about Indian Test captain Shubman Gill, calling him overconfident and prone to reckless shots. Speaking about Gill’s leadership potential, Panesar said the young batsman lacks the consistency and intensity across all formats required to emulate the likes of Virat Kohli.

Gill’s All-Format Captaincy Questioned
Panesar, who played a key role in England’s victories over India in home conditions, told ANI, “Gill is a talented cricketer, but he becomes complacent at times and plays careless shots early in his innings. Virat Kohli’s intensity and aggression were visible in every format. Gill cannot do the same. Expecting him to lead across all formats is too much of a burden.”

While acknowledging Gill’s natural talent, Panesar highlighted that the Indian team currently feels weaker in Test cricket, especially in Kohli’s absence. He explained that while the team can manage in white-ball cricket (ODIs and T20Is), Kohli’s absence in Tests is deeply felt, impacting the team’s aggression and momentum.

Domestic System and Player Priorities Under Scrutiny
Panesar also criticized the domestic cricket system in India, pointing out the gap between Ranji Trophy level and Test cricket. He argued that many young players prioritize IPL contracts and limited-overs cricket over four-day first-class or Test matches. “Players want big contracts and international exposure in T20s and ODIs. Four-day cricket requires hard work, which they are unwilling to give time for,” Panesar said. He also noted that financial incentives for T20 cricket far outweigh those in the longer formats, affecting players’ priorities and readiness for Test cricket.

Gautam Gambhir’s Role in Red-Ball Coaching
While praising Gautam Gambhir for his white-ball coaching expertise, Panesar suggested that Gambhir still has much to learn in red-ball coaching. He recommended that Gambhir gain experience in Ranji Trophy coaching and consult seasoned coaches to better prepare India’s Test side.

A Wake-Up Call for Indian Cricket
Panesar’s remarks come at a time when India has faced a disappointing Test season, including clean sweeps at the hands of New Zealand (3-0) and South Africa (2-0). His critique underscores the challenges young Indian cricketers face in balancing IPL fame and financial incentives with the discipline and rigor demanded by Test cricket.

Monty Panesar, who took 167 wickets in 50 Tests for England, including 36 wickets in 11 Tests against India, believes that a return to Test dominance will require time, patience, and a renewed focus on red-ball cricket.