Heated Exchanges in Rajya Sabha Over Opposition’s Right to Speak; ‘Abodh and Captive’ Remark Sparks Controversy

New Delhi: The Rajya Sabha witnessed a fiery confrontation between the ruling and opposition parties on Thursday, shortly after proceedings began. Union Minister J.P. Nadda urged members not to disrupt the House and referred to Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, saying, “Do not make an innocent child a captive.” Nadda emphasized that discussions on Lok Sabha proceedings cannot take place in the Rajya Sabha.

Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge quickly retaliated, asserting, “Your party has been held captive by Modi ji; you cannot speak without his opinion. Do not lecture us about our party.” Kharge further argued that Parliament comprises both Houses and that the opposition in the Lok Sabha was denied the opportunity to speak on national interests, questioning how the House could be conducted in this manner.

Amid the commotion, Union Minister of Parliamentary Affairs Kiren Rijiju appealed to all members to adhere to parliamentary rules and traditions, noting that MPs were awaiting the Prime Minister’s address.

The situation escalated when Kharge was not allowed to quote excerpts from General M.M. Naravane’s book, prompting opposition members to stage a walkout. Congress MP K.C. Venugopal told reporters outside the House that in a parliamentary democracy, the opposition leader has the right to speak and initiate debate — a right that was completely denied in this instance. He emphasized that their sole demand is to allow the opposition leader to exercise this right.