‘This Is Urban Phobia’: Supreme Court Rejects PIL Seeking Higher Standards for Bottled Drinking Water
The Supreme Court on Wednesday dismissed a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) seeking stricter standards for bottled drinking water, describing the plea as “luxury litigation” driven by “urban phobia.” A Bench headed by Chief Justice of India Justice Suryakant observed that a significant portion of India’s population is still struggling to access even basic clean drinking water.
Rejecting the petition, the Court emphasized that concerns over premium quality standards cannot override the ground reality faced by millions, especially in rural areas where people continue to depend largely on groundwater for drinking purposes.
“Quality Comes Later”
Addressing the petitioner, Sarang Vaman Yadavdkar, the CJI remarked,
“In this country, people are still deprived of clean drinking water. ...









